UCSC, Santa Cruz, and Water: The Deal Was Made a Long Time Ago

Santa Cruz promised UCSC water in the 1960s to win the campus, and an appeals court has upheld that deal. The real question isn't whether UCSC gets water. It's how growth can use less.

I want to start with something that tends to get lost whenever Santa Cruz argues about UC Santa Cruz. The City didn't get stuck with a university. It went after one.

In the early 1960s, Santa Cruz was competing with other locations to persuade the UC Regents to build on the Cowell Ranch, and it won partly by making promises. One of those promises was water. In 1962, the City agreed to bring water and sewer lines to the campus boundary, at no cost to the university, as development required. A 1965 agreement went further and required a system able to deliver up to 2 million gallons a day for fire flow and ordinary use.

The size of the university matters here, because it changes how the whole debate looks. These promises weren't made for a small liberal-arts college tucked into the redwoods. UCSC's original 1963 Long Range Development Plan imagined 27,500 students by 1990, spread across 15 to 20 colleges and professional schools. The current 2021 plan allows for up to 28,000 students by 2040. In other words, the university Santa Cruz is fighting about today is roughly the university Santa Cruz asked for sixty years ago.

So what has actually changed? Mostly, how much water we use.

The Demand Story is Better than you Think

The City's water system now uses about 2.6 billion gallons a year, down from a peak of roughly 4.5 billion around 2000, even as the population has grown. The 2025 Urban Water Management Plan projects only slow growth from here, to about 2.9 billion by mid-century.

UCSC has followed the same curve. Main-campus use fell from 179 million gallons in 2012–13 to about 154 million in 2017–18, while enrollment rose.

Growth will push demand back up, and that shouldn't be minimized. The university projects main-campus and Westside Research Park demand rising to 289.1 million gallons by 2040, with roughly another 10 million for the Coastal Science Campus at buildout. That works out to about 134.6 million additional gallons a year, or around 5.2% of the City's entire current demand.

That's real. But two things are true at once. The number is meaningful, and it's also unlikely to materialize, because it assumes UCSC stops getting more efficient. Given its track record, that's a hard assumption to believe.

The 8,000 Students Who Haven't Shown Up

There's a second reason that projection is unlikely, and it should cool the temperature of this whole debate. UCSC isn't close to 28,000 students, and it isn't racing toward that number.

Total enrollment for fall 2025 was 20,140, including 18,194 undergraduates and 1,946 graduate students. Two years earlier, despite accepting a record number of first-year students, UCSC's overall undergraduate enrollment held flat at about 17,800. And this fall, UC Santa Cruz saw its first drop in undergraduate applications in five years, down 7.3%, even as national numbers rose.

That leaves the campus roughly 8,000 students short of its planning capacity, with fourteen years to go and no sign of a surge.

This matters for the water math. The 134.6-million-gallon plan assumes UCSC reaches full buildout and also stops getting more efficient. Both have to happen for the number to come true, and right now neither looks likely.

That doesn't make the concerns disappear. Plans exist to set ceilings, and the UC system as a whole is still growing, so enrollment could pick up. But it does change the question. We're not debating a flood of students arriving next year. We're debating how to prepare for growth that may come slowly, partly, or not at all, and that's a much easier problem to plan for than the one people tend to imagine.

UCSC has Water Beneath its Feet

This is the part of the story I find most interesting, because it reframes the question.

UCSC sits on a karst aquifer it has studied for decades. Its WSW#1 well in Jordan Gulch passed a seven-day pumping test in 1989 at 100 gallons per minute, and a 72-hour test in 2007 averaging 92.5. The university's own evaluation calls that rate sustainable, with minimal drawdown and no visible effect on off-site springs. That's roughly 48.6 million gallons a year.

I don't want to oversell this. The well is planned for non-potable uses: the campus farm, the Arboretum, drought relief, and backup supply. Those uses total about 10 million gallons today, rising to around 12 million by 2040. Most of the potential growth is drinking water for people, since residential use alone more than doubles, from 75 million to 169 million gallons. Untreated groundwater can't cover that.

But the well points somewhere useful. Groundwater for irrigation, recycled water, and continued conservation could each shrink what UCSC ultimately draws from the City. That's a negotiation about engineering, which is a much better negotiation to be having.

Can the City simply say no?

This is where history turns into law.

In November 2024, California's Sixth District Court of Appeal read the 1962 and 1965 agreements and directed the trial court to declare that Santa Cruz must deliver water to the campus boundary. Once the water arrives, UCSC can distribute it anywhere on campus, including new development outside City limits. The court rejected the idea that LAFCO approval was required before City water could serve North Campus, though it also found the City hadn't breached the agreements by seeking that approval.

The paper trail points the same direction. In the 2008 Comprehensive Settlement Agreement, both sides stated explicitly that it did not "change, modify, or alter" the original contracts. That settlement was tied to a plan that has since been replaced, but it shows both parties treated the 1960s deals as intact.

The limits matter too. The 2024 opinion is unpublished, so it generally can't serve as precedent in unrelated cases, although it does settle the core dispute between these two parties. It also doesn't give UCSC unlimited water under every circumstance. As a City customer, the university remains subject to drought allocations and demand-reduction rules, and questions about system capacity or the 2-million-gallon provision could raise different issues.

Still, a City Council trying to simply reverse the basic obligation would be up against a promise Santa Cruz made voluntarily and a court that has now told it what that promise means.

What About the Recent Court Decision on UCSC Growth?

A separate case, over the 2021 plan's Environmental Impact Report, has been getting conflated with the water ruling, and it's worth untangling.

Start with the number. The 28,000 figure is a planning capacity, not a mandate. It's about 44% above the 19,500 in the 2005 plan, but 19,500 was never a permanent, court-imposed cap. It was the level written into a plan and settlement that have since been superseded.

The environmental case also doesn't bar UCSC from reaching 28,000. Its central question is narrower and, I think, sharper: did the university adequately analyze what happens to the surrounding community, especially housing, if enrollment grows faster than campus beds get built? The 2021 plan promises housing for 100% of new students above 19,500. The fight is over what happens if that promise slips. Given today's flat enrollment, that risk looks more manageable than it once did, but it's still the right thing to watch.

The Better Question

None of this means residents should shrug. Santa Cruz in 2026 faces housing, traffic, environmental, and infrastructure pressures that 1963 couldn't have imagined, and those concerns are legitimate.

But I'd suggest that "should UCSC grow?" is the wrong question, and that the community will keep losing time on it. The more productive question is what conditions should come with growth. How much housing should be finished before enrollment rises? How do we handle transportation? How much City water should UCSC actually need, and how much can conservation, groundwater, and recycled water offset? Which parts of the campus deserve protection?

Those are questions the City, the university, and the community can actually work through together. They just have to start from the facts: what the plan actually proposes, what the courts have actually decided, and what authority the City does and doesn't have.

The deal was made a long time ago. What we decide now is how well we keep it.

Update

According to the university, UCSC has added nearly 1,000 beds of new student housing over that same period, and about 3,000 more on-campus beds are in the pipeline. UCSC says it remains one of the few UC and CSU campuses housing more than half of its students, and that it plans to raise that share over the next decade.

The university also says its 2021 Long Range Development Plan is often mischaracterized. UCSC describes an LRDP as similar to a city or county general plan: a planning tool that identifies the best places to add buildings, transportation, and facilities over 20 years, if the university decides to build them, rather than a commitment to do so. UCSC notes that the plan requires on-campus housing for 100% of all new student growth and 25% of employee growth.

Sources

  • UCSC 2021 Long Range Development Plan — The university's official plan for accommodating as many as 28,000 students through 2040, including housing, infrastructure and sustainability planning.
    Read the UCSC LRDP

  • UCSC 2021 LRDP Water Supply Evaluation (EIR Appendix J) — Potential campus water demand through 2040, the WSW#1 groundwater well, and the history of the 1962 and 1965 agreements.
    Read the UCSC water supply evaluation

  • City of Santa Cruz 2025 Urban Water Management Plan — The City's current assessment of water demand, supplies, drought reliability and potential future needs.
    Read the City's water plan

  • Regents of the University of California v. City of Santa Cruz (2024) — The Sixth District Court of Appeal decision interpreting the City's obligations under the 1962 and 1965 UCSC water agreements.
    Read about the Court of Appeal decision

  • UCSC Hydrology and Water Quality Analysis — The university's environmental analysis describing the campus karst aquifer and results of groundwater pumping tests.
    Read the groundwater analysis

Related Articles

Previous
Previous

Clean Oceans International Is Hiring a Paid Intern

Next
Next

Santa Cruz's Next Economic Opportunity May Already Live Here